“Hi Wes, for some reason, this reply box did not show up earlier”
Anytime that happens just click your Reload button on your Browser. It’s a browser cache issue with bbPress Forum, and W3TC cache plugin – https://appfinite.com/topic/having-trouble-logging-in/
Anyways, it looks like you’re using a different theme? If you still plan to use the Guru theme just let me know and I can see what’s going on. It shouldn’t take too long to get fixed.
If possible, I can see what the issue is faster with a Temporary login. Just let me know.