I spent a good while checking the code in each and every file. I disabled/reenabled every plugin, and also uploaded a second version of the Aspire theme and I still could not figure out what was causing this issue!
I reactivated the original Theme you’re using again and manually installed each widget back into their widget locations and now everything is working. This was the first time I’ve seen that happen on a site.
I still have no idea what was causing that issue before, but it seems to be working perfectly fine now. Let me know if it happens again.